How Should We View Transgender Individuals Before Gender Reassignment Surgery Entering Women-Only Facilities?

| Input:

[Dr. Park Chang-beom to Doctor]

In over 20 European countries, individuals can change their legal gender simply by self-declaration. Photo = Clipart Korea

Recently, in over 20 European countries including Germany, the UK, and France, individuals can change their legal gender without submitting medical records or a diagnosis recognizing the physical and mental sexual incongruence to the court, simply by ‘self-declaration’. As a result, transgender individuals can apply for gender change without hormone therapy or gender reassignment surgery, and can also change it back after a year. With the growing social support for the right to pursue happiness and diversity, the criteria for determining gender have shifted from medical standards to the gender recognized by the individual.

In line with this trend, our country is also changing. In 2006, the Supreme Court made a decision allowing legal gender correction, creating administrative guidelines (Family Relationship Registration Regulations) that included criteria for approval, such as whether the individual had undergone gender reassignment surgery, whether their external genitalia had changed to that of the opposite sex, and whether they had lost reproductive ability. In 2020, the Supreme Court changed the status of external genitalia and loss of reproductive ability from ‘investigation items’ to ‘reference items’ in the relevant regulations. In May 2023, the National Human Rights Commission recommended that the Supreme Court change its guidelines to prevent human rights violations and advised the Speaker of the National Assembly to enact special laws. However, in almost all lower courts, applicants have been required to undergo gender reassignment surgery to approve gender correction.

However, recent rulings have shown a different trend. It has been stated that even if an individual does not undergo gender reassignment surgery, if they are receiving hormone therapy and can be evaluated as having transitioned to the gender they have felt throughout their life, considering their perception of gender and social environment, gender correction can be approved (Cheongju District Court Yeongdong Branch, April 3, 2024, Decision No. 1033, etc.).

It is also true that there are concerns about relaxing the requirements for gender correction to not require gender reassignment surgery. The most representative concern is where a transgender individual who has received gender correction approval but still has male genitalia would use public baths, saunas, and changing rooms. If they were to use male saunas or changing rooms, it would be uncomfortable for the transgender individual. However, if they were to use female saunas or changing rooms, it would make the surrounding women uncomfortable.

In response, the court pointed out in its ruling that the fear that a transgender individual who has not removed their genitalia would pose a threat in public baths or restrooms is due to a lack of understanding of transgender individuals by the general public, and it is hard to imagine a transgender person wanting to become a different gender being rejected by people of that gender or exposed to hateful gazes. In fact, individual A has experienced violence and has been unable to use public restrooms. (Kyung Hyang Newspaper, Court “Cannot Force Surgery for Transgender Gender Correction”, August 14, 2025.)

In the United States, the feared situation has occurred. According to a 2023 report, a transgender individual who was receiving hormone injections but had not undergone gender reassignment surgery and still had male genitalia attempted to use the women’s changing room at a yoga studio, leading to some women in the changing room shouting and expressing discomfort. As a result, the yoga studio prohibited the transgender individual from using the women’s changing room, and the transgender individual claimed that the studio’s actions caused them shame, humiliation, and frustration, filing a civil lawsuit for $5 million.

Similarly, in 2022, a transgender individual registered as a woman but possessing male genitalia attempted to use a jjimjilbang (Korean sauna) in New Jersey, but the jjimjilbang staff questioned them about their gender reassignment surgery and genital status. When they answered that they had male genitalia, they were directed to use the male facilities. However, the transgender individual refused this. The jjimjilbang then suggested that they could use the women’s facilities if they wore a swimsuit, but they did not accept this and filed a lawsuit. After the lawsuit in 2025, the jjimjilbang changed its policy to allow all customers to use the gendered areas that match their gender identity, regardless of whether they had undergone gender reassignment surgery, stating that customers should understand that there may be individuals in those areas with bodies that do not conform to typical gender norms.

Similar incidents have occurred in our country as well. A transgender individual who appeared to have a female appearance but had not yet undergone genital removal or reassignment surgery was in a situation requiring hospitalization. The hospital’s administrative department placed them in a male multi-person room or single room, citing that they had not undergone gender reassignment surgery and their resident registration number was male. The transgender individual filed a complaint with the National Human Rights Commission, arguing that the hospital’s decision to place them in a male ward was discriminatory.

The National Human Rights Commission decided that health authorities need to improve accessibility for transgender individuals in using medical facilities and ensure that they are not excluded from medical services such as hospitalization due to their gender identity. (National Human Rights Commission, September 13, 2022, Decision No. 21-Complaint-0749500)

It is true that there are various concerns arising from allowing transgender individuals to legally transition without undergoing gender reassignment surgery. Many people agree that the sexual self-determination rights of transgender individuals and their right not to have their bodies violated must be protected. However, to concretely realize this, the discomfort of many people must also be considered. I believe that there will need to be extensive discussions on how to address these issues in the future.

×