Pork Belly, Butter and Genes: Who Needs to Watch Their Cholesterol Most Closely?

| Input:

A Stanford-led analysis of nearly 21,000 U.S. postmenopausal women finds that high saturated fat intake hits LDL cholesterol hardest—and raises cardiovascular risk—in people with a strong genetic predisposition

A beef steak on a cutting board. Stanford University researchers found that the link between saturated fat intake and blood LDL cholesterol levels may vary depending on genetic predisposition. This image is unrelated to the study. Photo=Shixart1985 · Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0), recreated with AI based on the original photo
A beef steak on a cutting board. Stanford University researchers found that the link between saturated fat intake and blood LDL cholesterol levels may vary depending on genetic predisposition. This image is unrelated to the study. Photo=Shixart1985 · Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0), recreated with AI based on the original photo

Do some people need to be extra careful about their cholesterol when eating foods high in saturated fat, such as pork belly or butter?

A new study finds that the greater a person’s genetic predisposition to high cholesterol, the stronger the link between saturated fat intake and blood cholesterol levels. Women with both high genetic risk and high saturated fat intake also faced a significantly higher risk of developing cardiovascular disease.

A research team led by Stanford University School of Medicine analyzed genetic data, dietary habits and blood test results from 20,940 postmenopausal women in the U.S. Women’s Health Initiative (WHI). The findings were published on Nov. 18 in the international journal JACC: Advances.

Higher genetic risk strengthens the link between saturated fat and LDL

To assess diet, researchers asked participants how often and how much they consumed 122 types of food and beverages over the previous three months, using those responses to calculate the share of total calories coming from saturated fat.

They then measured LDL cholesterol levels through blood tests and analyzed 7,812 genetic variants tied to LDL levels using existing genetic data, combining each variant’s effect into an individual genetic risk score. LDL is commonly known as “bad cholesterol” because it contributes to plaque buildup in artery walls.

When the researchers split participants into two groups by genetic risk score, the median LDL level in the higher-risk half was 162 mg/dL—27 mg/dL higher than the 135 mg/dL median in the lower-risk half, after adjusting for cholesterol-lowering medication.

Examining how diet interacted with those genes revealed a clear split. Among women with higher genetic risk, LDL levels rose noticeably as saturated fat intake increased, whereas the association was relatively weaker among women with lower genetic risk. The pattern suggests that how strongly saturated fat affects cholesterol depends in part on genetic predisposition.

Blood testing in a laboratory. Stanford University School of Medicine researchers found that the link between saturated fat intake and blood LDL levels was stronger among women with a greater genetic predisposition to elevated LDL cholesterol. This image is unrelated to the study. Photo=Ja muzalevskaya · Wikimedia Commons (CC0)
Blood testing in a laboratory. Stanford University School of Medicine researchers found that the link between saturated fat intake and blood LDL levels was stronger among women with a greater genetic predisposition to elevated LDL cholesterol. This image is unrelated to the study. Photo=Ja muzalevskaya · Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

Cardiovascular disease incidence reaches 14.3% when both risk factors overlap

In a follow-up analysis of 16,835 women—excluding participants with prior cardiovascular disease or those enrolled in a low-fat dietary intervention trial—1,582 women (9.4%) developed atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, including heart attacks and strokes, over up to 10 years of follow-up.

The team then divided those participants into four groups based on whether their genetic risk and saturated fat intake each fell in the top 25%.

The 10-year cumulative incidence was 9.5% among women in neither top-25% group, 10.4% among those in the top 25% for saturated fat intake alone, and 9.8% among those in the top 25% for genetic risk alone. By contrast, incidence jumped to 14.3% among women in the top 25% for both measures.

That gap held even after accounting for other risk factors such as age, weight and smoking: women with both high risk factors had a 45% higher risk of developing cardiovascular disease than those in neither top-25% group. Even after further adjusting for estimated pretreatment LDL levels (accounting for cholesterol-lowering drugs), their risk remained 29% higher.

Diet still matters—especially for those with high genetic risk

“People with a genetic predisposition to higher LDL levels were actually the most sensitive to diet,” said Shoa Clarke, a professor at Stanford University School of Medicine who led the study. That means dietary choices could help them more—or, conversely, harm them more. Even for people with low genetic risk, Clarke emphasized, there is no evidence that eating large amounts of saturated fat benefits cardiovascular health.

Saturated fat is abundant in fatty meats such as pork belly, as well as butter and cheese. In its 2026 dietary guidance for cardiovascular health, the American Heart Association recommended cutting back on foods high in saturated fat and choosing foods rich in unsaturated fat, such as fish, nuts and olive oil.

Still, the researchers noted important caveats. Because this was an observational study examining associations between diet and genetics rather than a clinical trial testing dietary changes, it cannot prove how much LDL levels drop when saturated fat intake is reduced—or confirm that people with high genetic risk gain more from changing their diets.

In addition, because the study included only postmenopausal women, further research is needed to see whether the same patterns hold in men and younger adults.

×